Don’t Call Me A Slut

Kuber Sharma

No I will not be going for the Slut Walk in New Delhi on 25th June. No, its not because I cannot bear to go for a march in 44 degree centigrade. No, its not because I am not a slut (anyways since am a man, I cant be one. Worst case scenario I can be a stud). No its not because I don’t agree with the core message, that sexual assault is an act of violence by perpetrator and not invited by the victim. But I do not think the Slut Walk is the way to go about ‘Social Change’. I have a couple of rants against the Sluts walking the streets (no pun intended).

First of all, is it necessary to label yourself Slut? Wikipedia tells us it refers to an individual with loose sexual morals. Yesterday I was in an interesting twitter discussion (with women friends) where we came up with alternate names such as RandiWalk, RaandWalk and even SelectCitiSlutWalk. Yes we were being funny, but no we were not being ironic. Are we implying that women who dress a certain way actually are sluts? Are we mainstreaming the term? Do we want every woman who wears a short skirt to be referred as a slut? Because I don’t have to dress a certain way to be a slut. Right? Seriously folks, we need to think a bit about this legitimizing of a term forced upon by judging prudes! Some commentators are referring to this phenomenon as reclaiming of the term by the feminists, but I’ll rather try to bury such misogynist terms. I remember an old Blank Noise initiative in which they collected clothes from victims of street harassment, the clothes they were wearing when hey were harassed. And they collected a large pile of everyday clothes. Simple message: one does not have to dress provocatively to be sexually harassed. But the Slut Walk takes the clothing argument to a different tangent!

Secondly, in my extremely humble opinion, I don't think that's what the majority of people looking at this march would get the actual point behind it. I read somewhere that it’s akin to the 'pole dancing as empowering' branch of post-feminism which I find quite vile. Every one knows that street harassment ‘happens’ so what’s new being told? Ok, I am going to be a little provocative here. From what I understand most of these protests are followed by hoards of leering men. Now I shudder at the thought of what’s going to happen in Delhi. Seriously. I know because a few years back I would have bee one of these men shooting the ‘sluts’ on my camera phone and uploading on debonairblog.com. The organizers of the Slut Walks across the globe are forgetting one simple thing. If you want to stop men from harassing women, then involve men talk to men about it. Dialog with them, understand their perspective and also involve some of them for your cause. Just going ahead and declaring a war on them will not solve anything. Think of recent efforts in Delhi that talk about Violence Against Women such as Please Mend The Gap had serious male partnership. We need clarity, are they reclaiming the term, or are they reclaiming the right to dress the way they want to or are they just trying to feel empowered by doing something radical? Or is it about recognizing the issue of street sexual harassment and getting round to doing something about it???

I am loving the outrageousness, I agree with the devilmaycare attitude, I admire the spirit and I sympathize with the cause. But I just don’t want to be a slut!

 

Do you agree with the blog post? Or maybe not? Must Bol is an interactive space and we will love to hear from you in the comments section...   

Also dont forget to invite your friends & Participate in conversation with the Must Bol campaign on Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/DelhiYouth) and Twitter (http://twitter.com/mustbol)

 

Tags:Comment Share: 

Comments

There are people dying like houseflies in terrorist attacks, there are thousands starving to death while tonnes of food grains rot in our so called godowns, there are are millions whose lives depend on whether they get to fill a bucket of water in the morning to last them the remainder of the day, in every village in India there is a woman who has to walk twenty kilometers up and down to fill her pot with water, for the well twelve yards away belongs to a Brahmin, and there are plenty of soot-eyed skull-cap wearing men who, while going to the mosque' have to be at the receiving end of accusatory, suspicious stares. I couldn't care a muck about what you pseudo-intellectuals think about a word.

I think the problem began from the point where it was named SlutWalk. That says two things- either we are choosy in who we call a slut or we are generalizing the females as sluts, both of which stand far away from the truth. The truth is that there is sexual harassment on the streets and simply roping in people for a mass walk is no solution to the problem. The solution is not simple. But naming such walks in such one- sided light is plainly defeating your own purpose at the sound of the word Go! I am not against change, but changing with a tag attached to the change is ridiculous. Going through all the comments, I could see that either there is support or opposition to the blog. I am not standing on either side, but the opposition needs to search for some better arguments to fight upon. That is the reason why it seems that the feminists are reclaiming the term. And those here who think they don't need clarity are in the direst need of clarity.
Lastly, everyone please start looking at things without any preconceived notions in your head. I am not here to defend anyone. But the reality and the truth is that SlutWalk seems a failure in itself as it has already been painted in a color which looks at every woman in dim light. There are two dimensions to how people look at things- Right or Wrong. But theses dimensions do not always address the Truth. Please start looking at the Truth and stop thinking in terms of right and wrong from the very start. Truth does not have any dimension as it is complete in itself. Even a five- year old child is aware of it.

Walk if that makes you happy but at the end of the day please understand the reasons behind the problem . sex ratio,movie,(india specific),old fashioned culture
http://globalnewsdiscussion.com/index.php?topic=90.0

Tupur, good comments. Would there be a way to tailor SlutWalk's ideas to something that would be more effective in Delhi?

So after all I ended up writing the long piece I wanted to write.Its a bit long, but hopefully not boring. Just to briefly mention my stand, I have nothing against the campaign in its entirety, but am strongly in disapproval of the Slut Walk Delhi. To presume just because something is getting popular in western cities must be immediately brought to India in exactly the same fashion without contextualizing it is very euro-centric. The word slut has very little use in the Indian vocabulary. Slut Walk in Delhi therefore makes no sense.

Read the rest of my article here - http://sanjukta.wordpress.com/2011/06/10/the-slut-walk-comes-to-delhi-wh...

This entire idea of transporting a 'slut walk' from the West to New Delhi is strange. Who exactly are you addressing here? I'm not sure your average non-exposed to words like 'slut' Delhi male is going to get either aware or sensitized to the issue at hand. It seems to be a dialogue between upper class, English educated men and women, who write realms on the topic on their blogs and websites and then argue with each other and go around circles. I'm talking about people like us- our male and female friends already know that calling a woman a slut/whore because of the way she dresses is demeaning and distasteful- if they do it anyway, it's only because they have mindsets they really aren't terribly bothered about changing. We are already aware. For the rest of the middle/lower-middle class/poor population in this city, the slut walk means nothing but a bunch of skimpily clad women walking the streets together carrying slogans about words they don't understand. They can probably hang around in front of any night club in the city to witness the same thing.

On the contrary, the word 'Raandi' means prostitute, and all truck divers on highways know that prostitutes wear saris.

Why jump on to Canada's bandwagon, in India? We are a country where only 10% or less of the population even knows what the term even means. The causes for rape and sexual harassment in Delhi have other deep social and psychological roots that go back to decades of sexual repression, power politics, patriarchy, economy and several other things. I can be walking out in a salwar kameez at 8 am in the morning and be groped by a man passing by, I wasn't asking for it then. I could be in a night club dancing in a short skirt and be date raped. I wasn't asking for it then either. The Slut Walk is a great concept for countries where most males instantly recognize and identify the connotations of the word slut. By passing cultural connotations and living in our upper middle class/rich bubble is really isn't the solution.

I think you've missed the whole point of SlutWalk. The message behind the moniker is that calling someone a "slut" is not an excuse to rape them--that no matter what someone wears or how they act, non-consent remains non-consent.

Re men and SlutWalk, I don't know about others around the world, but our SlutWalk was attended by many, many men and there has been a dialogue between the sexes in Australia regarding the marches.

I respond to most of your concerns here: http://zenobiafrost.wordpress.com/2011/06/01/why-i-walked-the-slutwalk/

Well written Kuber, pretty much summed up my points.

i don't understand how you are differentiating between slutwalk and others like mendthegap and blanknoise. most of the things you are saying here can be picked up and applied to the latter two, with little if any changes. slutwalk is in essence also flash mob. i am not necessarily disagreeing with what you are saying here, just wondering if it dsn't apply to other rich delhi ac room- internet "awareness campaigns"?

The point is EVEN if I am a slut NO ONE has the right to assault me sexually, physically, mentally. It is not about morality or the definition of slut!

not to say that the slut walk is the most empowering\fresh\ground-breaking idea ever, but this discussion totally ignores people who are sluts, of any type of body. humara kya hoga, aap toh kisi higher moral social code ki hi baat kar rahe hain bus! :)

Since when is loose morals a positive value? Since when is pronouncing/highlighting divisions of man' and 'woman' 'cool'? Since when is 'keeping men out' an 'in thing to do'? Seriously, Slut Walkers, think! Else you'll just be silly sheep following a yet another mind-numbingly stupid herder! Think, Women, think!

Agree to what ur saying..though i really like that women now have the courage to come out n speak against sexual harassment but slut walk might not be the answer or the solution we are looking for. In my opinion it will grab attention for all the wrong reasons, and not for the cause but maybe bcos its called the slutwalk...and we don't want that. Plus India is not America. Things are different here and people have a totally diff. mindset. Just a personal opinion.

Really well written.

What does it matter what Wikipedia has defined a ‘slut’ as, as you should already know, the word slut is a socially constructed concept, that has been created to moralise and shame the behaviour, dress and role of women. It’s a bit worrying that you are referencing your sources from Wikipedia, the credibility of such a site is most definitely doubtful to say the least!

Slut Walks are not only for women, they are for men as well, this walk is part of the dialogue, it’s an event open for men and women to support against slut shaming and victim blaming. Mend the Gap does admirable work and addresses the issue of harassment on the metro, but Slut Walk too involves men in their campaigns. A slut walk is an in your face protest that hopes to highlight, that women are NOT the cause of sexual assault and rape and that we will not ignore it. This is not a war on men in the least this is a war on power. As you well know rape and sexual assault is not about sex per se but the power over another individual, it just so happens that men are most often the perpetrators to these crimes, but this does not mean there are not many men who are actively involved in the cause for women’s rights who will be walking right alongside me. Your implication that Slut Walk does not foster a serious partnership with men is quiet frankly insulting. Have a look at the Facebook page and see how many men are supporting Slut Walk and if they are there to check women out- as you say would have done a few years back then so be it. That’s what the Slut Walk is all about, it’s about saying “Hey, it doesn’t matter what I’m wearing, I am not asking for harassment, I am not asking for sexual assault, I am not asking for rape”

You claim “Some commentators are referring to this phenomenon as reclaiming of the term by the feminists, but I’ll rather try to bury such misogynist terms.” You don’t want to be called a slut because this word holds too many negative and demeaning connotations for you. But it’s for this reason, that I want to reclaim such a word. You yourself have given the word ‘slut’ the power of misogyny, instead I would like to embrace it, break it down and make it meaningless. Only then will we be able to shift society’s ideas of what a slut or even a Randi is and only then will we stop using such words to describe women in derogatory terms, especially.

You say ‘we need clarity...” Who is we? I certainly don’t need clarity. I know what Slut Walk aims to do. It is all that you listed in your final paragraph “reclaiming the term, or are they reclaiming the right to dress the way they want to or are they just trying to feel empowered by doing something radical? Or is it about recognizing the issue of street sexual harassment and getting round to doing something about it???” It’s all of those things and why can’t it be?

As you do, I too love the outrageousness, the spirit and the attitude. You can call me a slut if you like!

“No Means No; Yes Means Yes; Wherever We Go; However We Dress.”

Sure... please frame a word for men with 'loose' sexual morals and we will not call you slut.
please frame a demeaning word for men who use the services of sluts,
please frame a word for those who call women names just because she wants to live by rules, and all those who rape/harass/intimidate women..
and WE WILL NOT CALL YOU A SLUT!!!

This is precisely why i decided against getting involved with the Slut walk.

One simple point i wish to make, taking off from what you mentioned - "slut" is an English word, and the general population is unaware of its meaning/origin. For them, watching a bunch of women traipsing around in whatever they want to wear is "tamaasha", and nothing more.

I doubt that any of these women are going to approach the gawking men and talk to them. Sorry but you need to adapt and improve programmes in order for them to work in your specific surroundings. Slut Walk is a good idea, but needs MAJOR edits.

The name for starters. Slut or not, the average woman would not want to come close to being associated with that word. Am i being mean ? Possibly, with a purpose.

Harassment happens even when you dont wear provocative clothes...does not imply...that harassment does not happen when you do wear provocative clothes...

Agree with every word written. And also what may apply to NYC need to necessarily work in Delhi.

Whole heartedly agree. "Declaring war is not an answer" -gold. Got to cater to our enviroms..cut copy paste is not a solution.even Mc donalds is aware.

Post new comment

Must Bol Videos

Caught
What happens when the predator becomes the victim. Watch...
7492 views | 0 votes
Must Bol @ Amity
A Slogan writing writing competition on how to challenge...
6912 views | 0 votes
O bhai
Stolen gazes and explicit comments on women are masculine...
5417 views | 0 votes
The Fine Line
What is care and what is control? What is right and what is...
5194 views | 0 votes
Rocky the Lover!
Rocky loves his girlfriend a lot. But he has his own way to...
4922 views | 0 votes
We believe that Men can play an active role in eradicating violence against women. With this Blogathon, we want to collect ideas, thoughts and experiences of diverse men and women on the importance of men’s role and the urgency of the issue.

Recent Entries

Zennia Bhattacharjee - Men Can (make a difference) 
 -5th December 2011 
Aakash Yadav - Story of a Man
 -5th December 2011
Dipika Chaurasia - Bringing Up Men
 -5th December 2011
Ipsita Sengupta - Taken for Granted
 
-4th December 2011